John Dudley Broad Head

John Dudley Broadheads are highly regarded in the world of archery for their remarkable performance and precision. They’ve garnered attention for their distinctive attributes like amazing sharpness straight out of the box and unrivaled accuracy. They do require some maintenance, but it’s minimal compared to other options. You’d be hard-pressed to find another brand with such stellar push force tests results. This is just the tip of the arrow, though. The John Dudley line is a treasure trove of exciting features waiting for further exploration. If you’re an archery enthusiast, they’re worth a closer look.

Iron Will Broadheads

If you’re a hunter seeking a superior broadhead, you should definitely consider the Iron Will S100, a four-blade broadhead known for its excellent edge retention, durability, and impressive performance in various tests. This broadhead is crafted from 0.062-inch A2 tool steel, a reliable material that guarantees longevity and functionality. It’s available in various weights, ranging from 100 to 250 grains, allowing you to pick the right fit for your hunting needs.

The Iron Will S100, in testing, displayed remarkable sharpness right out of the box. It measured 289 grams in the sharpness test, indicating it’s more than capable of making a clean, quick kill. What’s more, it retained its sharpness even after use, requiring only minimal stropping to be hunt-ready again. Its sharpness retention was within 20 grams of its original measurement, the best in this particular test. However, due to A2 being a carbon steel, to maintain its sharpness in the field, it’s advisable to apply a rust preventative like Axe Wax.

In the push force test, the Iron Will S100 outperformed the competition, requiring only a cumulative score of 48.3 pounds to push through all media. This means it’s ideal if you’re shooting at a low draw weight, using a recurve bow, or targeting elk at a distance. The only downside reported by users is light blood trails. However, with its superior edge retention and durability, the Iron Will S100 is an excellent choice for any serious hunter.

G5 Montec M3

While the Iron Will S100 excels in many areas, another broadhead that warrants your attention is the G5 Montec M3, known for its superior penetration and quietness in flight. The G5 Montec M3 is a top-performing three-blade broadhead that is highly recommended for elk hunters, particularly those who prioritize penetration.

The G5 Montec M3 has several key features that set it apart:

1. Superior Push Force: The Montec M3 tops the chart among three-blade broadheads in a push force test, demonstrating a combined push force of 80.3 pounds. This impressive result indicates the broadhead’s superior penetration power, which is essential for successful elk hunting.
2. Quietness in Flight: One of the key strengths of the G5 Montec M3 is its quietness during flight. This feature allows for a stealthier approach, increasing your chances of a successful hunt.
3. Ease of Sharpening: The G5 Montec M3 is designed to be easily sharpened with a flat stone or touched up on a ceramic rod. This easy maintenance feature extends the broadhead’s lifespan, offering you better value for money.

However, it’s worth noting that the G5 Montec M3 has a higher push force than the best two and four-blade heads. This could potentially impact its performance in certain scenarios. However, considering the overall benefits, the G5 Montec M3 remains one of the best broadheads for elk, particularly for hunters with shorter draw-length and low-poundage bows.

>>Check latest price on Amazon

G5 DeadMeat V2

Switching gears to the G5 DeadMeat V2, you’ll find it’s a rear-deploying mechanical broadhead that stands out for its sharpness and large wound channel. Available in 100 or 125 grains, the Deadmeat V2 features blades retained by a collar rather than a band, a design element that offers the advantage of easy reset in case of premature blade deployment.

In testing, the Deadmeat V2 impressed with one of the largest wound channels recorded – a whopping 2.04 inches. It also showed excellent sharpness right out of the box, and it managed to retain this edge throughout rigorous durability testing. The Deadmeat V2’s sharpness and unique tip design greatly aided its penetration, evidenced by its solid performance in the push force test. It managed to rank second among all the mechanicals tested, despite its large cutting diameter.

In terms of accuracy, the Deadmeat V2 delivered a respectable 40-yard group average of 2 inches. It’s worth noting that this broadhead also comes with a match-grade practice head. This allows you to test the broadhead’s flight characteristics with a target that won’t be damaged, a feature that certainly adds value for the user.

However, it’s not without its flaws. Some users have reported instances of premature blade deployment. But, considering its overall performance and features, the G5 Deadmeat V2 stands as one of the most accurate and devastating mechanical broadheads available, making it a worthy choice for any serious bowhunter.

>>Check price on Amazon

SEVR Titanium 1.5 and 2.0

Continuing our examination of broadhead options, let’s now explore the SEVR Titanium 1.5 and 2.0, known for their accuracy, large entry holes, and durability. These broadheads, available in both 100 and 125-grain weights, are constructed from grade-5 titanium ferrule and stainless steel blades. An interesting feature is their rear-deploying blades, which not only create a significant entry hole but also pivot around bone, increasing penetration.

Let’s delve into some specifics:

1. Accuracy: The SEVR Titanium broadheads shine in this area. They were the most accurate mechanical broadheads in tests, with group averages of 1.25 and 1.5 inches at 40 yards.
2. Durability: The blades showed minor wrinkling in durability tests but didn’t bend or break. This suggests that while the blades are better used once, the ferrule can withstand multiple uses.
3. Entry Holes: The rear-deploying blade design leads to large entry holes, which can have a devastating effect on game.

However, there’s room for improvement. You may notice blade rattling in your quiver, although this can be mitigated with wax. Additionally, not all SEVR broadheads come sharp out of the box, so check and sharpen if necessary. Another drawback is the exposed arms in the open position which can cause drag. Sharpening the arms could minimize this issue.

Magnus Stinger

Let’s now turn our attention to the Magnus Stinger, a stainless steel broadhead renowned for its affordability and high performance in push force tests. This broadhead comes in weights ranging from 85 to 150 grains and is available in either a two or four blade design. The Stinger is a cost-effective option, priced around $40 for a pack of three.

The Stinger’s performance in accuracy tests was commendable, achieving a group average of 2.56 inches at 40 yards. It also passed the durability test unscathed, further establishing its reliability. However, in the sharpness test, results were mixed. Two of the three heads met the 400-gram requirement, but one fell short, suggesting you might need to touch up the Stingers straight out of the pack.

In terms of push force, the Stingers were standout performers, coming in fourth right behind more expensive heads. This indicates their ability to penetrate well, a critical attribute in hunting. However, their measured wound channel was 1.08 inches, slightly reduced due to the bleeder blades not cutting the gel in the tests.

The Magnus Stinger’s overall performance, affordability, and lifetime warranty make it a worthwhile consideration, particularly for those on a budget. If you’re seeking a broadhead that combines cost-effectiveness with decent performance, the Stinger could be an ideal choice. Just remember, as with any hunting gear, individual preferences and testing results should guide your choice.

>>Check latest price on Amazon

Conclusion

To sum up, the John Dudley Broadhead excels in terms of precision, durability, and performance. It competes with top contenders like Iron Will Broadheads and G5 Montec M3 with its unique features. Whether you’re a seasoned elk hunter or a newbie, this broadhead is worth considering. Remember, the right broadhead can make or break your hunting season, so choose wisely. With the John Dudley Broadhead, you’re one step closer to a successful hunt.